Calculate colored sources with explicit assumptions
Updated
There is no universal source count for one, two, or three colored pips. You also need a desired casting turn, a draw model, a deck size, and an acceptable chance of success. State those assumptions before comparing a mana base.
Bring this calculation to your deck: build a mana base or review the model and data sources.
Use a probability model, not a copied table
Frank Karsten’s work explains the importance of matching colored sources to spell requirements. A table calibrated for another format or mulligan model does not become a Commander table by multiplying its counts.
Landfiller’s colored-mana calculator uses an exact hypergeometric tail for draws without replacement. It reports the chance of seeing at least the required sources in the chosen number of cards. This is narrower than the chance of casting the spell.
Count sources that are available in time
A land that can produce both blue and green is one potential source of each color; it cannot produce both with a single tap. Do not give pain lands an arbitrary fractional discount.
Conditional lands, fetches with missing targets, tapped entry, and rocks with activation costs can make nominal source counts optimistic. Count them separately and review your intended turn sequence. Sol Ring does not produce colored mana.
Check demanding costs first
List early spells with repeated colored pips and the commander’s cost. Test a double-blue spell on turn two separately from a double-blue spell on turn five.
Compare the current source count with one extra source and a later casting turn. A multi-color land can help several requirements, but its entry condition still matters.
- 01Choose the target spell and intended turn
- 02Set a 99-card library and explicit cards-seen count
- 03Count usable sources for that color
- 04Inspect the reported probability and timing limitations
- 05Change a slot and test the real sequence
Worked example: two blue sources
For a 99-card library, seven-card opener and one draw each turn including turn one, turn two means nine cards seen. The following are exact chances of seeing at least two blue sources, with no mulligans, extra draws or ramp. This is our calculation, not a quoted Karsten table; seeing sources does not guarantee casting Counterspell.
- ◆20 blue sources, nine cards seen: 58.0%.
- ◆25 blue sources, nine cards seen: 71.8%.
- ◆30 blue sources, nine cards seen: 82.2%.
- ◆25 blue sources, twelve cards seen (turn five): 86.3%.
Understand the builder’s targets
The builder uses source allocation heuristics plus deck pip analysis when supplied. Those targets guide a budgeted land selection; they do not guarantee every spell is cast on curve.
An imported deck provides more useful cost information than a commander alone. Recheck the full list when you change the curve, commander, or mana rocks.
Questions & Answers
FAQ
How many blue sources does Counterspell need?
Choose the desired casting turn and cards seen, then calculate the probability of seeing two blue sources. There is no single source count independent of those assumptions.
Do mana rocks count?
Only if they can produce the relevant color by the intended turn. Review the mana needed to cast and activate them. Sol Ring does not produce blue, white, black, red, or green.
Does seeing enough sources guarantee casting?
No. You must also draw the spell, have enough total mana, satisfy entry and activation conditions, and sequence the cards correctly.
Keep reading
Related guides
How many lands does your Commander deck need?
Start around 37 lands, calculate land-drop odds for a 99-card library, and refine the count using your curve and playtest notes.
Choosing fetch lands for Commander
Compare fetch-land targets, tapped entry, activation costs and landfall benefits before upgrading your Commander mana base.
Building a budget Commander mana base
Plan a budget Commander mana base with basics, color-source checks, tapped-land tradeoffs, and upgrades matched to your early spells.